25/26Switchbacks FC → TB Rowdies—
24/25New Mexico Utd. → Switchbacks FC—
23/24Columbus 2 → New Mexico Utd.—
21/22Tormenta FC → Columbus 2—
18/19Akron Zips → Tormenta FC—
18/19Young Harris → Akron Zips—
18/19Tormenta FC → Young Harris—
17/18Young Harris → Tormenta FC—
17/18Reading United → Young Harris—
16/17Young Harris → Reading United—
16/17Charlotte → Young Harris—
15/16Young Harris → Charlotte—
