25/26Indy Eleven → Fort Wayne—
23/24Switchbacks FC → Indy Eleven—
22/23Phoenix Rising → Switchbacks FC—
20/21Without Club → Phoenix Rising—
20/21Minnesota → Without Club—
19/20Phoenix Rising → Minnesota—
17/18Kansas City → Phoenix Rising—
17/18Swope Park → Kansas City—
17/18Kansas City → Swope Park—
17/18Swope Park → Kansas City—
16/17St. Louis FC → Swope Park—
15/16Team Wellington → St. Louis FC—
15/16St. Louis FC → Team Wellington—
14/15Team Wellington → St. Louis FC—
14/15South Melbourne → Team Wellington—
13/14Team Wellington → South Melbourne—
13/14Fulham FC U21 → Team Wellington—
12/13Hereford Utd. → Fulham FC U21—
12/13Fulham FC U21 → Hereford Utd.—
12/13Team Wellington → Fulham FC U21—
11/12Wellington → Team Wellington—
10/11Whanganui AFC → Wellington—
