20/21Handsworth → Retired—
20/21Worksop → Handsworth—
19/20Sheffield FC → Worksop—
18/19Ossett Albion → Sheffield FC—
17/18Frickley Athletic → Ossett Albion—
16/17Goole AFC → Frickley Athletic—
15/16Sheffield FC → Goole AFC—
14/15Goole AFC → Sheffield FC—
13/14Unknown → Goole AFC—
12/13Sheffield FC → Unknown—
11/12Frickley Athletic → Sheffield FC—
10/11Unknown → Frickley Athletic—
09/10Belper Town → Unknown—
08/09Mansfield Town → Belper Town—
08/09Sheff Wed → Mansfield Town—
07/08Guiseley → Sheff Wed—
07/08Sheff Wed → Guiseley—
07/08Sheff Wed U18 → Sheff Wed—
