25/26Hearts of Pine → Corpus Christi—
24/25Without Club → Hearts of Pine—
24/25Knoxville → Without Club—
24/25Hailstorm FC → Knoxville—
23/24Knoxville → Hailstorm FC—
22/23Greenville → Knoxville—
21/22Forward Madison → Greenville—
20/21Greenville → Forward Madison—
18/19St. Pat's → Greenville—
17/18FC Edmonton → St. Pat's—
15/16Galway United → FC Edmonton—
13/141.FCA Darmstadt → Galway United—
13/14Jersey Express → 1.FCA Darmstadt—
12/13Without Club → Jersey Express—
12/13Philadelphia → Without Club—
12/13SUNY Binghamton → Philadelphia—
12/13Westchester → SUNY Binghamton—
11/12SUNY Binghamton → Westchester—
11/12Westchester → SUNY Binghamton—
10/11SUNY Binghamton → Westchester—
