25/26Pittsburgh → Indy Eleven—
23/24Minnesota → Pittsburgh—
21/22Columbus → Minnesota—
21/22Indy Eleven → Columbus—
20/21Columbus → Indy Eleven—
20/21Kansas City → Columbus—
20/21Phoenix Rising → Kansas City—
19/20Kansas City → Phoenix Rising—
19/20Kansas City II → Kansas City—
19/20Kansas City → Kansas City II—
19/20Tulsa → Kansas City—
18/19Kansas City → Roughnecks FC—
18/19Swope Park → Kansas City—
18/19Kansas City → Swope Park—
18/19Swope Park → Kansas City—
17/18Kansas City → Swope Park—
17/18Butler Bulldogs → Kansas City—
17/18OKC Energy U-23 → Butler Bulldogs—
16/17Butler Bulldogs → OKC Energy U-23—
15/16P. Timbers U23 → Butler Bulldogs—
14/15Butler Bulldogs → P. Timbers U23—
13/14Indy Academy → Butler Bulldogs—
