23/24Tulsa → Spokane—
22/23Kansas City II → Tulsa—
21/22Bold FC → Kansas City II—
20/21Without Club → Bold FC—
20/21Tacoma Defiance → Without Club—
19/20St. Louis FC → Tacoma Defiance—
19/20Phoenix Rising → St. Louis FC—
17/18Chicago → Phoenix Rising—
17/18Roughnecks FC → Chicago—
16/17Chicago → Roughnecks FC—
16/17St. Louis FC → Chicago—
15/16Chicago → St. Louis FC—
15/16Louisville City → Chicago—
14/15Chicago → Louisville City—
14/15Fire Academy → Chicago—
